| Family, (# residents) | Residence/Owner | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Original house | ||
| Bernard Ekon & daughter | ~1660-1693 | 33 |
| . . . |
Slator Clay & Family(15) Captain, Proprietor "Indian Head" Trustee New Castle Common (1764) |
1740-1789 | 49 |
| Current house | ||
| James McCullough & Family Captain, Proprietor ships's store Trustee New Castle Common: Jas. (1832), Wm. H. (1841) | 1815-1846 | 31 |
| Non resident real estate investors Sheriff Platt->Howell Terry->Alfred Noland |
1846-1854 | - |
| Maria, Samuel & Elizabeth Guthrie,
and cook and husband (4-5) Lawyer | 1854-1903 | 45 |
| Julia Jefferson Dungan & Family (3) Julia: 'Angel of Mercy', & James, clerk, Ann J. Dungan, daughter | 1903-1965 | 62 |
| Viola Steves White Dolan Hodge (2) | 1965-1970 | 5 |
| Wm. T. Quillen & Family (4) Delaware Supreme Court Justice, Chancellor, Sec. of State Carol Quillen, Pres. Davidson College Tracey Quillen Carney, Delaware First Lady |
1970-2004 | 34 |
| Jim & Rita Meek & Family (4) | 2004-2022 | 18 |
| AVERAGE | 37 | |